Back To Blog

To Build New or Buy a Resale...That is the Question

Navigating the Shenandoah Valley Market: Buying Existing vs. Building New in Harrisonburg and Rockingham, VA

The Shenandoah Valley, encompassing Harrisonburg and Rockingham, VA, offers a beautiful setting for your dream home. But whether to buy an existing home or build new can be a difficult decision in the current market. This blog post, from Valley Realty Associates, explores the pros and cons of each approach to help you make an informed choice.

Buying Existing Inventory:


  • Move-in Ready: Existing homes are typically available to move in much sooner than new constructions. This can be crucial if you're facing a tight timeline or need to relocate quickly.

  • Established Neighborhoods: Existing homes are often situated in established neighborhoods with mature landscaping, existing amenities like parks and schools, and a sense of community.

  • Potential for Unique Character: Existing homes often hold historical charm, architectural details, and unique features not readily available in new constructions.

  • Potentially Lower Cost: Depending on the specific property and market conditions, existing homes might offer a more cost-effective option, especially considering rising material costs for new builds.


  • Limited Options: With lower inventory, finding an existing home that perfectly matches your needs and preferences can be challenging, and you might need to compromise on certain features.

  • Potential for Repairs and Updates: Existing homes may require repairs, renovations, or upgrades to meet your desired standards, adding to the initial cost.

  • Uncertainties about Previous Work: It's crucial to conduct thorough inspections to understand the home's condition and potential underlying issues.

Building New:


  • Customization: Building a new home allows you to personalize every aspect, from the floor plan and finishes to the selection of appliances and fixtures, ensuring it perfectly matches your needs and desires.

  • Modern Amenities and Efficiency: New homes typically incorporate modern design features, energy-efficient appliances, and the latest building codes, potentially leading to lower utility bills and long-term cost savings.

  • Warranty Coverage: New constructions come with builder warranties, providing peace of mind and protection against potential issues related to construction or materials.

  • No Renovation Hassles: You move into a brand-new home with no need for immediate repairs or renovations.


  • Longer Wait Time: Building a new home can take several months, requiring patience and potentially hindering your desired timeline.

  • Higher Cost: Building a new home typically comes at a higher initial cost compared to existing options, especially considering rising material and labor costs.

  • Limited Lot Selection: Available lots for new construction might be limited, potentially restricting your desired location or neighborhood.

  • Unforeseen Delays: Construction projects can experience unexpected delays due to weather, material availability, or unforeseen circumstances.

The Final Decision:

Ultimately, the choice between buying existing or building new depends on your individual priorities, needs, and preferences. Consider your budget, desired timeline, and the importance of customization versus established neighborhoods.

Valley Realty Associates: Your Trusted Guide in the Shenandoah Valley

At Valley Realty Associates, we understand the complexities of navigating the real estate market. We offer expertise and guidance throughout your journey, whether you're searching for existing inventory or exploring new construction options. Contact us today to discuss your specific needs and let us help you find your perfect home in the beautiful Shenandoah Valley.

Call: (540-236-5800)   Email:

Together, let's turn your dream into reality!


Add Comment

Comments are moderated. Please be patient if your comment does not appear immediately. Thank you.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.


  1. No comments. Be the first to comment.